October 18, 2010
The Emperor's New Clothes - Vers. 2.0

Posted by Jim Lichtman | What do you think?

Once upon a time, in a country wide and beautiful, there was a very audacious and flamboyant financier who liked to wear very nice clothes. (Here he is in his gold tie and pinstripe finery.)

One day, this very daring man saw a need in the housing market, and lo, with a skill for salesmanship and the help of the best money lenders he could find, he concocted a scheme by which many, many, MANY people were able to purchase a home for the unheard of price of… nothing down.

At the time, the scheme came with the catchy industry title, “affordability products.” With the help of many, many, MANY others, they called this brilliant scheme… “subprime lending.”

Well the people of the wide and beautiful country thought this was wonderful. “Now we can have the home of our dreams without worry,” shouted Jane and Joe Doe.

And lo, the man with the scheme was able to buy more and better finery. He was even able to afford his own in-home spray-tan salon which he availed himself of, frequently.

Such was the genius of this very bold man that citizens far and wide in this country would come and avail themselves of the scheme until lo, the man’s company became “a mortgage lending behemoth with $11.4 billion in revenue at its peak in 2006,” according to The New York Times (Oct. 16).

Over an eight year period, this very extraordinary man became an Emperor in this new land of mortgage lending, and befitting his position, was richly rewarded to the tune of “$521.5 million, according to Equilar, a compensation research firm.”

One day, however, the stylishly tailored Emperor was called to Congress to answer some very serious questions about how and why this scheme came about and the great burden it now placed on ALL the people in the country wide and beautiful. (Here he is testifying before Congress in his red silk tie and suit.)

Finally, in 2009, a great and powerful overseer called the Securities and Exchange Commission sued the Emperor and his colleagues, accusing them of “hiding growing risks from investors.” (This, despite the fact, that the SEC chose not to look more closely until the scheme was well underway and many, many, MANY people were affected by the bad loans.)

And what did the great and powerful SEC have in its possesion as evidence of this risk hiding?

A series of e-mails written by the Emperor himself showed that even he did not have much faith in the scheme. “In all my years in the business, I have never seen a more toxic product.”  And, “[I have] personally observed a serious lack of compliance within our origination system as it relates to documentation in the quality of loans originated.”

Well, with evidence like that, what could the Emperor do?

And so it happened that four days before the Emperor and his colleagues were to appear before a jury in a federal court, the Emperor with the help of many, many, MANY attorneys settled fraud charges for $67.5 million. It was determined that the Emperor “would pay $22.5 million in penalties and $45 million in ‘disgorgement,’” (ouch) of stocks returned to the company’s shareholders, according to The Wall Street Journal (Oct. 16). 

However, in agreeing to the settlement, the Emperor “and his colleagues neither admitted nor denied the government’s charges,” so we can only conclude that the Emperor offered the money as a one-time donation to promote the good work of the great and powerful overseer.

And what of the people who had subprime loans and the citizens of the country wide and beautiful who continue to carry the burden brought about by the scheme? 

Well, they got screwed. 

And the Emperor?

Well, he can never, ever, EVER serve on a public company again. BUT he does get to keep all his real nice clothes as well as a lifetime of security. 

 

  Reader Comments

Comments by John, D.C., October 20, 2010

Thats the kind of right cross we like from you, Jim!

Comments by Julian, CA, October 20, 2010

I love the piece on, well... karma. And the intoxication of power. People talk to me about who they think should be elected to this or that office in DC and I keep reminding people that whoever goes there, steps into that den of power - will be swallowed by its Jeckle/Hyde effect.

I hand an inkling of how that happens one day when I was 21 years old and had the opportunity to drive a Rolls Royce out of La Jolla, through the streets of San Diego, and across the border into Mexico. As I sat in that car and looked through tinted glass windows at the people looking at the car from the sidewalk, I imagined that they might be wondering if we were rock stars or rich Hollywood famous people in the car. I got all swollen in my ego center. It shocked me. I instantly knew that I was as vulnerable to becoming an arrogant, ruthless crusher of my fellow humans as the next guy. I’m glad to have caught that drift at such a young age. And I know that I would be vulnerable to the disease of power were it dropped into my lap today.

I think that, as a society, we need to remove envy from our script. If we were to not envy powerful people, then maybe we would not aspire to such toxic heights. Just a thought...

The story about Sir Countrywide... I am not proud of my vulnerability to feel vindictive rage. In the end, I am such a silly human.

Comments by Debbie, ID, October 20, 2010

Very interesting!!!

Comments by Laura, AZ, October 19, 2010

Perfect!  Although I sure wish that the universe wasn't providing you with this abundance of topics. Nothing personal, you understand -- I wish you a happy profusion of work -- it's just what a sorry thing our country is so rife with all these blatant ethical violations.

Comments by Gordon, TX, October, 18, 2010                                  

Loved the article...thanks for sending.  This guy just looks like a crook.  Never did I ever understand why B of A took a flyer on Countrywide. 

Comments by Kat, OH, October 18, 2010

Excellent summation of the Mozilo fiasco!

Comments by Kathryn, CA, October 18, 2010

That's a good one, Jim.  Makes me so angry.

Comments by Harold, NYC, October 18, 2010

Ahhh, America...

Comments by Steve, CA, October 18, 2010

Very clever and a good chuckle.

Comments by Mike, TX, October 18, 2010

For a tanned viper wearing silk ties to foster a scheme such as subprime mortgages in a wide and beautiful country such as this, the scam required many, many, MANY stupid little mice. Greedy, short-sighted mice who, in some ways, felt a certain sense of entitlement, albeit on a much, MUCH smaller scale than Mr. Asp. Just ask any farmer in this wide and beautiful country what happens when there are too many hungry rodents ... The snakes are sure to follow.

Comments by Kat, OH, October 18, 2010

Excellent summation of the Mozilo fiasco!

Comments by Sandra, NYC, October 18, 2010

Very well written!

Comments by Sue, CA, October 18, 2010

I LOVED this column.  Simply amazing!

Comments by Myles, CA, October 18, 2010

Very good!  If only the Overseer had enough smart people to truly oversee what goes on!

Comments by Terry, CA, October 18, 2010

With nice clothes and a lifetime of security, who needs to "serve" on any more public companies?  God bless america and the people on whose backs he made his mint. Good piece.

 

 
 
  HOME | about-jim | archives | articles | be-honest | books | excerpt | fame-shame | hero | quotes | suggested-links | Site Map | FAQ  
  copyright © 2010 Jim Lichtman